Ranking · Herkimer County

ZIP codes with the highest home values in Herkimer County, NY

These are the 21 ZIP codes in Herkimer County with the highest median home value, out of 21 with at least 1,000 residents. 13420 (Old Forge, $355,200), 13304 (Barneveld, $300,000) and 13456 (Sauquoit, $259,800) lead the list. There is no single "best" ZIP code in Herkimer County; the right one depends on who you want to reach, so the same ZIP codes are ranked several ways below.

Top 21 of 21 ZIP codes

Median home value, ± 90% margin of error where published. ZIP codes with fewer than 1,000 residents are not ranked.

ZIP codes with the highest home values in Herkimer County, NY
#ZIPMailing cityMedian home valueResidentsHouseholdsMailboxes
113420Old Forge$355,200±$45,2541,05546987
213304Barneveld$300,000±$57,9181,653638655
313456Sauquoit$259,800±$25,9623,8481,3791,586
413431Poland$245,100±$34,5191,847734637
513413New Hartford$240,400±$15,02416,7427,0356,816
613322Clayville$204,800±$24,6021,172429474
713438Remsen$192,900±$20,6153,0651,4101,479
813439Richfield Springs$185,600±$20,3033,6811,3961,268
913416Newport$185,500±$14,1552,369930668
1013324Cold Brook$179,300±$17,0121,729778937
1113338Forestport$176,300±$66,0361,280582658
1213367Lowville$171,000±$8,5448,6013,4563,495
1313502Utica$158,000±$6,46334,03714,21014,402
1413340Frankfort$157,800±$11,5767,4043,2953,367
1513491West Winfield$151,400±$12,4673,4311,2671,363
1613407Mohawk$149,100±$22,8825,0422,1812,236
1713350Herkimer$136,800±$22,0079,5224,1434,135
1813365Little Falls$130,500±$18,2928,5783,4753,623
1913329Dolgeville$121,700±$10,4903,2561,3811,606
2013357Ilion$115,600±$10,85710,1674,6524,480
2113339Fort Plain$94,400±$6,2936,0102,3542,603
Loading ZIP codes…

Orange outlines and badges mark the top 10. Shading covers every ranked ZIP code in Herkimer County, in fifths.

Which of these to mail, and why

Home value tracks what owners spend on the house itself: renovations, landscaping, pest control, security, interior design. Pair it with the homeowner share so the mailer reaches owners, not tenants.

The top five ZIP codes on this list hold 10,255 households, on 25 carrier routes with 9,781 residential mailboxes. Open any of them on the route map to see each carrier route's own figures before you choose.

Start with the top ZIP codes on the route map and keep only the carrier routes that fit.

Open 13420 on the route map

How we ranked them

Ranked by median value of owner-occupied homes as reported by owners (ACS 5-year estimates, 2020–2024). Published medians are capped at $2,000,000. 21 of the 28 ZIP codes in Herkimer County, NY have at least 1,000 residents and a published figure. ZIP codes can extend past Herkimer County's boundary; see how ZIP codes are assigned.

More rankings

Frequently asked questions

Which ZIP code in Herkimer County has the highest median home value?

13420 (Old Forge), at $355,200 (±$45,254), among 21 ZIP codes with at least 1,000 residents.

How is this ranking calculated?

Ranked by median value of owner-occupied homes as reported by owners (ACS 5-year estimates, 2020–2024). Published medians are capped at $2,000,000.

Why are some ZIP codes missing?

ZIP codes with fewer than 1,000 residents are left out because their survey estimates swing too much to rank, and so are ZIP codes where the Census Bureau did not publish this figure.

Sources & how to read these numbers

  • Demographics, income, housing, work and language: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey (ACS) 5-year estimates, 2020–2024. Trend figures use the 2010–2014 and 2015–2019 releases.
  • Resident and housing counts labeled "2020 Census": 2020 Decennial Census, Demographic and Housing Characteristics file.
  • Businesses: U.S. Census Bureau, ZIP Codes Business Patterns 2023 (establishments with paid employees).
  • Carrier routes and mailbox counts: USPS EDDM route data stored by EDDM2GO. Route-level demographics are EDDM2GO estimates that spread Census block-group figures along each route's streets; they are modeled, not counted. Route codes, route types and route sizes are explained in our USPS carrier routes guide.

ZIP codes vs. ZCTAs. The Census Bureau reports on ZIP Code Tabulation Areas (ZCTAs), which approximate the areas USPS ZIP codes serve. They usually line up closely but not perfectly, and PO-box-only ZIP codes have no ZCTA.

Margins of error. ACS figures are survey estimates. Hover a figure to see its 90% margin of error; the colored dot rates reliability (green reliable, amber use with care, red rough guide). "Compare to" benchmarks are weighted averages of every ZCTA in the state or nation, except where an official published median is shown.

This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau.