Which ZIP code in Suffolk County has the highest median home value?

11976 (Water Mill), at $2,000,000+, among 88 ZIP codes with at least 1,000 residents.

Why are some ZIP codes missing?

ZIP codes with fewer than 1,000 residents are left out because their survey estimates swing too much to rank, and so are ZIP codes where the Census Bureau did not publish this figure.

ZIP codes with the highest home values in Suffolk County, NY

These are the 25 ZIP codes in Suffolk County with the highest median home value, out of 88 with at least 1,000 residents. 11976 (Water Mill, $2,000,000+), 11724 (Cold Spring Harbor, $1,641,000) and 11954 (Montauk, $1,356,600) lead the list. There is no single "best" ZIP code in Suffolk County; the right one depends on who you want to reach, so the same ZIP codes are ranked several ways below.

ZIP codes with the highest home values in Suffolk County

Rank	ZIP	Mailing city	Median home value	Residents	Households	Residential mailboxes
1	11976	Water Mill	$2,000,000+	2,952	1,315	1,971
2	11724	Cold Spring Harbor	$1,641,000 ±$97,745	3,073	1,017	1,052
3	11954	Montauk	$1,356,600 ±$243,422	4,223	1,615	2,871
4	11968	Southampton	$1,326,600 ±$283,104	15,312	5,831	8,327
5	11963	Sag Harbor	$1,208,000 ±$96,451	8,390	3,613	4,761
6	11937	East Hampton	$1,115,100 ±$76,094	21,882	8,584	11,201
7	11964	Shelter Island	$1,078,500 ±$153,761	2,906	1,087	—
8	11977	Westhampton	$1,077,200 ±$82,217	2,843	1,041	1,461
9	11978	Westhampton Beach	$1,054,000 ±$109,462	4,705	1,704	2,223
10	11957	Orient	$973,700 ±$107,207	1,121	614	397
11	11935	Cutchogue	$915,900 ±$91,811	2,863	1,134	1,755
12	11944	Greenport	$885,800 ±$50,365	5,037	2,072	2,452
13	11939	East Marion	$857,800 ±$71,736	1,331	666	609
14	11739	Great River	$853,100 ±$26,811	1,225	472	—
15	11942	East Quogue	$844,100 ±$48,745	5,406	2,198	2,550
16	11971	Southold	$843,300 ±$51,371	6,361	2,437	3,186
17	11768	Northport	$801,700 ±$28,393	22,030	8,193	7,993
18	11743	Huntington	$783,100 ±$22,989	43,490	15,708	15,423
19	11718	Brightwaters	$768,600 ±$58,788	3,179	1,054	1,148
20	11952	Mattituck	$764,300 ±$85,364	5,040	2,017	1,906
21	11747	Melville	$757,800 ±$41,556	20,513	7,543	7,763
22	11721	Centerport	$740,300 ±$36,823	6,426	2,417	2,351
23	11946	Hampton Bays	$737,400 ±$37,300	15,819	6,096	7,276
24	11780	Saint James	$723,200 ±$33,838	15,018	5,459	5,605
25	11941	Eastport	$705,800 ±$73,852	2,814	1,017	1,045

How we ranked them

Ranked by median value of owner-occupied homes as reported by owners (ACS 5-year estimates, 2020–2024). Published medians are capped at $2,000,000. ZIP codes need at least 1,000 residents to be ranked; 88 of 108 qualify.

Which of these to mail, and why

Home value tracks what owners spend on the house itself: renovations, landscaping, pest control, security, interior design. Pair it with the homeowner share so the mailer reaches owners, not tenants.

The top five ZIP codes on this list hold 13,391 households, on 33 carrier routes with 18,982 residential mailboxes. Open any of them on the route map to see each carrier route's own figures before you choose.

Open 11976 on the EDDM route map

More rankings

Businesses that mail these ZIP codes

Map it and price it

EDDM guides

Frequently asked questions

Which ZIP code in Suffolk County has the highest median home value?: 11976 (Water Mill), at $2,000,000+, among 88 ZIP codes with at least 1,000 residents.
How is this ranking calculated?: Ranked by median value of owner-occupied homes as reported by owners (ACS 5-year estimates, 2020–2024). Published medians are capped at $2,000,000.
Why are some ZIP codes missing?: ZIP codes with fewer than 1,000 residents are left out because their survey estimates swing too much to rank, and so are ZIP codes where the Census Bureau did not publish this figure.

This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau.