Shelter Island, NY ZIP Codes
One ZIP code serves Shelter Island, New York: 11964. Together they are home to 2,906 residents in 1,087 households. That is more than the 2,125 people counted inside Shelter Island Census-designated place, because these ZIP codes reach past its boundary.
Published by the Census Bureau for the place itself (ACS 2020–2024). These are true medians, unlike the ZIP-based figures above.
- Residents
- 2,125
- Households
- 683
- Median household income
- $165,734
- Median home value
- $1,025,400
- Median age
- 41.3
- Median rent
- —
Map of Shelter Island ZIP codes
Each ZIP code shaded by the measure you pick, in fifths from lowest to highest within this area. Click a ZIP for its full profile.
Top facts
Among ZIP codes with at least 1,000 residents
- Too few populated ZIP codes to compare.
Every ZIP code in Shelter Island
Sort any column. Hover a figure for its margin of error.
| Mailing city | Why listed | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11964 | Shelter Island | 2,906 | 1,087 | $134,620 | $1,078,500 | 93% | 18% | 3% | 43.6 | — | — | 67% of its land · mailing city |
Carrier-route counts appear once a ZIP code is in our stored route library; the route map loads any ZIP code on demand.
A ZIP code is listed for Shelter Island when at least 10% of its land lies inside the Shelter Island Census-designated place, when it holds at least 10% of the place's land, or when its USPS mailing city is Shelter Island. The table shows which applies. Totals add up whole ZIP codes, so they include any parts outside Shelter Island.
Counties
Price a mailing to Shelter Island ZIP codes
Frequently asked questions
What ZIP codes are in Shelter Island, NY?
11964. A ZIP code is listed for Shelter Island when at least 10% of its land lies inside the Shelter Island Census-designated place, when it holds at least 10% of the place's land, or when its USPS mailing city is Shelter Island.
What is the population of Shelter Island, NY?
The Census Bureau counts 2,125 residents inside Shelter Island Census-designated place (ACS 2020–2024). The 1 ZIP code that serve Shelter Island hold 2,906 residents in all.
What is the median household income in Shelter Island, NY?
$165,734 inside Shelter Island Census-designated place, per the Census Bureau. Across its ZIP codes the medians run from $134,620 to $134,620.
Mail Shelter Island by carrier route
Pick the ZIP codes and routes that fit your offer on the route map; each route shows its homes, businesses and price before you order.